Build vs. Buy Cost Comparison

Enter costs for both options to see the break-even point and total cost comparison

Subscription amount per
Results are for informational purposes only and do not constitute financial or investment advice. Consult a qualified financial professional before making investment decisions.

Quick answer

Use this calculator to compare the total cost of building software in-house versus buying a SaaS solution. Enter your build costs (initial + maintenance + hosting) and subscription costs to see a year-by-year comparison, the break-even month, and a clear recommendation. Building is almost never cheaper in year one - but it often wins after year 5-7.

Key takeaways
  • Software maintenance comprises 80-90% of a system's total lifecycle cost, according to research cited by Wikipedia (Ulziit et al., 2015) - which is why build analyses that only count initial development cost are almost always wrong.
  • Build almost never wins in year one or two. Break-even typically requires 4-8 years when maintenance and hosting are modeled correctly.
  • 73% of SaaS vendors raised prices in 2023, with average software price inflation of 8.7% - more than double the US CPI rate that year (CFO Dive, citing Vertice, 2023). This compounding matters over a 5-10 year horizon.
  • The break-even calculation in this tool uses a geometric series formula to compound both maintenance growth and subscription price increases.
  • Build makes sense when: requirements are unique, the tool is core to your competitive advantage, or the subscription cost clearly exceeds build plus maintenance at the 5-year mark.

What does the build vs. buy decision really cost?

The build vs. buy question is one of the most consequential decisions a software team makes - yet most analyses get it wrong. Teams routinely compare the initial development cost to the first year's subscription and declare build the winner.

That comparison ignores the 80-90% of a software system's lifetime cost that comes from ongoing maintenance, security updates, infrastructure, and upgrades - not the initial build (Ulziit et al., 2015, via Wikipedia). And on the buy side, 73% of SaaS vendors raised prices in 2023 alone.

How to use this build or buy calculator

To use this calculator: enter your initial development cost, annual maintenance estimate, and monthly hosting in the Build section. Enter the setup fee and subscription cost in the Buy section. Set growth rates if you expect maintenance or subscription costs to rise annually. Choose the analysis period (3-10 years) and read the recommendation.

The calculator shows cumulative costs year by year, interpolates the break-even month, and labels the cheaper option over your chosen horizon. The year-by-year table highlights the break-even year with a checkmark.

Build vs. buy explained to a beginner

Imagine you need a coffee machine at the office. You could buy an espresso machine for $2,000 (build), or pay $80/month for a coffee service that delivers pods and maintains the machine (buy). In month one, build looks insane.

By month 25, the espresso machine has cost the same total as the service - that's the break-even point. After that, every month is cheaper on the espresso machine.

Now add: the espresso machine needs a service call every year ($300), and the pod service raises prices 5% annually. That's exactly what this calculator models for software.

The initial build cost is the espresso machine. Maintenance is the annual service call. The SaaS subscription is the pod service with annual price increases. Break-even is when the two lines cross.

What to include in build costs

Most build analyses undercount costs by 40-60% because they only capture obvious line items. A complete build cost model includes every cost that wouldn't exist if you bought instead.

Cost categoryWhat to includeTypical magnitude
Initial developmentEngineer salaries or contractor fees, design, project management, QA, documentation$50K-$500K+ depending on scope
Annual maintenanceBug fixes, dependency updates, security patches, minor features15-25% of initial build cost per year
Infrastructure / hostingCloud compute, storage, CDN, database, monitoring tools$200-$5,000/month depending on scale
IntegrationsConnecting to other internal systems, API development, data pipelinesOften 20-30% of initial build cost
Security and compliancePenetration testing, audits, GDPR/SOC2 compliance work$5K-$50K/year for regulated industries
Opportunity costWhat else the development team could have shipped insteadHardest to quantify, often the largest factor

The opportunity cost of developer time is the most frequently omitted and most significant cost. When your senior engineers spend six months building an internal CRM, they're not building the revenue-generating features on the product roadmap.

Use our salary to hourly calculator to convert annual salaries into an accurate project cost estimate. For product companies, this tradeoff can easily be worth more than the entire build cost.

In practice, I'd recommend setting the annual maintenance field to at least 15% of your initial build cost as a conservative floor - even for simple tools.

Complex software with many integrations typically lands at 20-25%. Using zero for maintenance is the single most common error in build vs. buy analyses.

What to include in buy costs

Buy analyses have their own blind spots. The headline subscription price is rarely the total cost of a SaaS solution - implementation, training, seat limits, and switching costs all add up.

Cost categoryWhat to includeNotes
Subscription feeBase license cost, annualizedUse the annual contract price, not the month-to-month rate
Setup / implementationOnboarding, configuration, data migration, trainingOften 1-3x the annual subscription for enterprise tools
Per-seat costsAdditional user licenses above the base tierAdd headcount growth to the subscription projection
Add-ons and overagesStorage limits, API call limits, premium featuresOften 20-50% above the base price in year 2+
Integration costsConnecting the SaaS to internal systems, often via middleware$5K-$30K one-time, plus ongoing API maintenance
Switching costCost to exit if you later decide to build or switch vendorsData export, retraining, rebuild of integrations

Switching cost is the most underweighted factor in buy decisions. Once a SaaS tool is embedded in workflows and data is locked in the vendor's format, the realistic cost to leave is often 2-3x the original implementation fee. This is why vendor lock-in deserves explicit consideration alongside price when evaluating buy options.

How break-even is calculated

The break-even point is the month at which cumulative build costs first equal or fall below cumulative buy costs. The calculator uses geometric series formulas to model both maintenance growth and subscription price increases accurately.

Build cumulative cost at year y:

$$\text{Build cost}(y) = C_0 + H \cdot y + M \cdot \frac{(1+g)^y - 1}{g}$$

Where C₀ is the initial development cost, H is annual hosting cost, M is year-1 maintenance, and g is the annual maintenance growth rate.

Buy cumulative cost at year y:

$$\text{Buy cost}(y) = S + A \cdot \frac{(1+r)^y - 1}{r}$$

Where S is the setup fee, A is the year-1 annual subscription cost, and r is the annual subscription price increase rate.

The difference (positive = build saves money):

$$\text{Savings} = \text{Buy cost}(Y) - \text{Build cost}(Y)$$

The calculator iterates year 1 through the maximum of your analysis period or 20 years to find the first year where build cumulative cost falls at or below buy cumulative cost. It then interpolates between that year and the previous year to give you the break-even in months, not just whole years.

When growth rates are zero, both formulas simplify to flat annual cost multiplied by years. The geometric series form handles the compounding case where g > 0 or r > 0.

When building makes sense

Build wins when the subscription cost is high relative to build complexity, when your requirements are genuinely unique, or when the product is so central to your business that you can't afford vendor dependency. Here are the clearest signals that building is the right call.

SignalWhy build wins
No SaaS covers >80% of your requirementsCustomization cost on a 60% fit often exceeds build cost within 2 years
Subscription price exceeds build + maintenance at year 5The cumulative math favors build; break-even is reachable
Tool is a core competitive advantageLetting a vendor own your core capability creates strategic risk
Deep integration with proprietary data or systemsAPI-based integrations with SaaS tools add cost and latency
High user volume with per-seat pricingPer-seat SaaS costs scale linearly; build costs do not
Regulated industry with strict data residency requirementsNot all SaaS vendors meet HIPAA, SOC2, or GDPR requirements

The team size and subscription model are the two biggest factors. If a SaaS tool charges per seat and you have 500 users at $20/seat/month ($120K/year), you can often build a focused internal tool for $150K and be in cost parity by year 2 - even with maintenance included. That math obviously flips if you only have 20 users.

When buying makes sense

Buy wins when speed-to-value matters, when your engineering team is best deployed on core product, or when the problem being solved is genuinely commodity functionality.

The majority of build vs. buy analyses should end in a buy decision - most internal software needs are not unique enough to justify the sustained maintenance commitment.

SignalWhy buy wins
Tool needed in weeks, not monthsSaaS deploys immediately; build takes 3-18 months before first useful version
Low user count with flat per-seat pricingSubscription cost stays predictable; build maintenance does not
Category is evolving rapidly (AI, analytics)SaaS vendor absorbs R&D cost; you get new features automatically
Engineering team is at capacity on core productOpportunity cost of diverting engineers exceeds subscription cost
Well-defined problem with mature SaaS solutionsCRM, HR, accounting, email - these are solved problems
Analysis period is under 3 yearsBuild almost never recoups initial investment in under 3 years

When I've reviewed software spend at my previous employer where engineering was the bottleneck, buying almost always won on the full model - even where build looked cheaper on a subscription vs. development cost comparison.

The factor that consistently tipped the analysis was the cost of one senior engineer's time for 3-6 months, which is frequently $60-$120K in salary alone, before the ongoing maintenance obligation.

Common mistakes in build vs. buy analyses

  • Forgetting ongoing maintenance: The single most common error. Industry benchmarks put annual maintenance at 15-25% of initial development cost. Missing this single line item routinely makes build appear 2-3x cheaper than reality over a 5-year horizon.
  • Using a 1-year analysis window: Build almost never wins at year one. Using a 1-year comparison biases every analysis toward buy, regardless of long-term economics. Use a 5-7 year window to capture the period where build costs flatten and subscription costs compound.
  • Ignoring subscription price escalation: 73% of SaaS vendors raised prices in 2023, with average software price inflation of 8.7% - more than double general CPI (Vertice, 2023). A $24K/year subscription at 8% annual growth costs $43K in year 10 - a 79% increase. Not modeling this understates the buy cost significantly.
  • Counting only developer time for initial build: Project management, QA, design, documentation, and stakeholder reviews typically add 30-50% to raw development time. A project estimated at 3 engineer-months often takes 5 calendar months when total effort is counted.
  • Excluding integration and onboarding costs for buy: Implementation fees for enterprise SaaS tools often equal or exceed the first year's subscription. A $24K/year tool with a $20K implementation fee has a true first-year cost of $44K - often missed when comparing to build.
  • Not modeling the switching cost: Build analyses typically don't account for the cost to exit a SaaS vendor in year 3 or 5 if the tool doesn't meet needs. Data migration, retraining, and integration rebuild can cost more than a year's subscription.

Frequently asked questions about build vs. buy

When should you build instead of buy?

Build when your requirements are genuinely unique and no off-the-shelf product covers more than 70-80% of them, when you need deep integration with proprietary systems, or when the subscription cost over 5+ years clearly exceeds build plus maintenance. Build also makes sense when the product is core to your competitive advantage and you can't afford vendor lock-in.

What hidden costs do most build vs. buy analyses miss?

The two most commonly missed costs are ongoing software maintenance (typically 15-25% of initial development cost per year) and the opportunity cost of developer time. When your engineering team builds internal tools, they're not building revenue-generating product. This opportunity cost is rarely included in build analyses but is often the largest single factor when total cost is calculated honestly.

What is the break-even point in a build vs. buy decision?

The break-even point is the month at which cumulative build costs (initial investment plus all maintenance and hosting) first equal cumulative buy costs (setup fee plus all subscription payments). After that point, building is cheaper on a cumulative basis. This calculator interpolates between years to give you the break-even in months, not just whole years.

Is building software always cheaper in the long run?

Not always. Build costs continue to grow as software requires maintenance, security patches, and infrastructure. If subscription prices stay flat or the vendor improves the product at their cost, the subscription can remain cheaper indefinitely. Build only wins the long-run cost race when maintenance stays modest relative to subscription savings - typically under 20% of initial cost per year.

What is the difference between build vs. buy and make vs. buy?

Make vs. buy is the broader strategic framework used in manufacturing and supply chain management - should a company produce a component internally or purchase it from a supplier? Build vs. buy is the software-specific application of the same principle. The underlying economics are identical; the terminology differs by industry.

Test your knowledge

Quiz: how well do you know build vs. buy?

5 questions · ~2 min

1. In the build vs. buy formula, what does the variable g represent?

ℹ In the build cost formula, g is the annual maintenance growth rate. If maintenance costs increase 10% per year, set g = 0.10. The buy formula uses r for the subscription price increase rate.

2. Research cited by Wikipedia puts software maintenance at what percentage of a system's total lifecycle cost?

ℹ According to research cited on Wikipedia (Ulziit et al., Journal of Software: Evolution and Process, 2015), software maintenance comprises 80-90% of the lifecycle cost. This is why build analyses that focus only on initial development cost regularly underestimate the true total cost.

3. A team builds software for $200,000. Annual maintenance is $40,000, hosting is $500/month. A SaaS alternative costs $5,000/month. After 3 years, which is cheaper?

ℹ Build cumulative (3 yr): $200K + ($40K x 3) + ($6K x 3) = $338K. Buy cumulative: $60K/yr x 3 = $180K. Buy wins by $158K at year 3. The high initial build cost is not yet offset by lower subscription costs.

4. What does the break-even point represent in a build vs. buy analysis?

ℹ Break-even is the first point (interpolated to months) where the cumulative total cost of building equals the cumulative total cost of buying. After this point, build becomes the cheaper option on a cumulative basis.

5. According to this page, what is the most common mistake in build vs. buy analyses?

ℹ The most common mistake is omitting ongoing maintenance. Industry benchmarks put annual maintenance at 15-25% of initial development cost. Missing this single line item routinely makes build appear 2-3x cheaper than reality over a 5-year horizon.

Key terms